Share your voice — Be featured in Notable Men
STRATEGY

Can South Carolina Eliminate Its Income Tax Without Playing Budget Games? Yes—If Columbia Has the Discipline

A responsible path to tax relief through government audits, spending restraint and economic growth. How independent audits, spending restraint and a gradual phaseout could eliminate South Carolina’s income tax while protecting essential services.

October 26, 2026 6 min read

Drew Johnson, Account Executive on Notable Men

Drew Johnson

Account Executive, Kelly Office Solutions

Can South Carolina Eliminate Its Income Tax Without Playing Budget Games? Yes—If Columbia Has the Discipline

During the legislative session, eliminating the state income tax became a major issue. Alan Wilson has made it a central theme of his gubernatorial campaign. This article explains what that proposal could look like and why it would likely happen gradually, rather than all at once.


Auditing Government Before Cutting Taxes


Wilson has proposed a Families First Audit Initiative, led by his Lieutenant Governor, Mike Reichenbach, to conduct independent performance audits of each state agency. The initiative is intended to examine state programs closely, determine whether they operate efficiently, identify duplications across agencies, and ensure they serve South Carolina residents as intended. Anyone who works in corporate America is familiar with this because corporations of all sizes have firms that come in to do audits periodically; this is no different.

 

The audit would cover several practical areas, including agency payrolls, vacant positions, administrative costs, duplicate programs, and unused property. For example, auditors could look for long-vacant jobs that remain funded, agencies paying for overlapping software systems, state-owned vehicles or buildings that are rarely used, or separate programs providing the same service to the same population. They would also review grants, economic-development incentives, and no-bid contracts to determine whether taxpayers are receiving measurable value. Using modern data tools, the audit could flag unusual payments, overbilling, duplicate invoices, or potential fraud. For too long, state programs have often been judged by how much money they spend rather than what they accomplish. The Families First Audit Initiative would change that by publishing findings, estimating potential savings, and outlining a corrective action plan.


What “no state income tax” means


This does not mean residents would stop paying federal taxes. Instead, South Carolina would stop taxing wages, self-employment income, taxable retirement income, income reported by many small business owners, and pass-through business income. As the plan phases in, South Carolina workers would see less state withholding from their paychecks and, eventually, no state income-tax withholding at all.

 

South Carolina has already begun the process.


South Carolina is not starting from scratch. The state has already begun moving in this direction. For tax year 2026, legislation signed by Governor McMaster changes the individual income-tax structure to 1.99% on income below $30,000 and 5.21% on income above that threshold, with a $966 subtraction. The law also allows automatic rate reductions when projected state revenue growth exceeds 5%. The challenge is that income taxes are projected to bring in approximately $6.4-$6.6 billion in FY 2026-27. That makes income tax the largest source of General Fund revenue, at roughly 44%. South Carolina can eliminate the individual income tax through a responsible, multi-year phased plan built on economic growth and spending reduction. But it must not eliminate one tax only to add another.


Why the income tax should be eliminated


South Carolina families and businesses are already under significant financial pressure from years of high inflation. Any meaningful relief would help residents make ends meet as their dollars stretch less than they did just a few years ago. Gradually eliminating the state income tax would keep more money in the hands of workers, entrepreneurs, and small-business owners, many of whom currently pay business income taxes through their individual returns. State income tax also makes South Carolina less competitive with states like Florida, which has no state income tax. Eliminating it would provide lasting, broad-based relief rather than another temporary rebate or narrow program. No economic-development incentive is stronger than one that benefits every citizen—not just large businesses.

 

This will not be easy. South Carolina’s income taxes generate $6.5 billion annually. If we eliminated it immediately, the recurring budget gap would be enormous. We can't cover that amount with one surplus, one audit, or by canceling a few large contracts. If we are honest about the challenges to eliminate the state income tax, we can replace political slogans with an achievable plan. Alan Wilson has a plan and will release a timeline when appropriate. Being honest about the costs strengthens the case for elimination by replacing political slogans with an achievable plan.


Eliminate it gradually—not overnight.


This will not be easy. South Carolina’s income tax generates about $6.5 billion each year and eliminating it immediately would create a major recurring budget gap. No single surplus, audit, or cancellation of a few large contracts can cover that shortfall. Being honest about the challenge makes the case for elimination stronger, not weaker. It shifts the debate from political slogans to a realistic, phased plan. Alan Wilson has a plan and will release a timeline when appropriate.

 

Current state law already provides a path to a zero rate. It allows additional rate reductions if projected growth is 5%, with each reduction limited to a $ 200 million revenue impact. A zero-tax rate should accelerate this structure and help achieve the goal of a zero-state income tax rate.

 

Economic growth can replace lost revenue.

 

South Carolina’s economy has grown significantly, with more residents working, earning, and contributing to the state’s momentum. Much of that progress reflects Governor Henry McMaster’s leadership. During his administration, the state has attracted new and expanding businesses, strengthened employment, raised wages, and increased collections from existing revenue sources. Lower income-tax rates can further encourage investment. Still, lawmakers should count growth conservatively and rely only on recurring revenue. Forecasts may signal opportunity, but they should not be treated as guaranteed income.

First, South Carolina must get its financial house in order by keeping spending under control. A fiscally responsible legislature and governor are essential to making income-tax elimination work. As noted above, Alan Wilson’s Families First Audit Initiative and a South Carolina DOGE-style mindset would be an important first step toward eliminating the state income tax.


Protect essential services


Any state income tax phase-in program must account for essential services such as Roads and bridges, public schools and teacher pay, law enforcement and corrections, school resource, emergency services, rural health care, and pension and debt payments. Required pension and debt payments. The latest state budget cut income taxes while adding $377 million for roads and bridges, raising the minimum starting teacher salary to $50,500, and funding law-enforcement raises. That provides a practical model: tax relief and core investment can advance together.


Do not rely on budget gimmicks.


A credible plan must reject budget gimmicks, such as using one-time surpluses for recurring tax cuts, draining the rainy-day fund, shifting programs off budget, or relying on unrealistic assumptions. These tactics do not solve the problem. South Carolina should not eliminate one tax only to replace it with several new ones; that is not reform, it is a shell game.

 

In conclusion, the case for eliminating South Carolina’s state income tax rests on several key points. People should keep more of what they earn, and meaningful payroll-tax relief would make a real difference for families. Having lived in Florida and benefited from a no-income-tax system, I know the impact can be significant. Government should also justify its spending and be held accountable through independent audits. Broad-based tax relief can strengthen economic growth and may help exceed the revenue-growth targets needed to continue reducing rates.

 

South Carolina has already shown it can reduce income taxes while continuing to fund important priorities. With discipline, the state can build on that progress and create a responsible path to fully eliminating the tax.

 

South Carolina does not have to choose between eliminating the income tax and maintaining strong schools, safe communities, and reliable roads. The state can reach a zero-income-tax future without raising sales or property taxes, but it will require legislative discipline and a governor like Alan Wilson, who has made this issue central to his campaign.

THE SUNDAY DISPATCH

The Week's Most Considered Piece, Delivered.

One letter every Sunday. The most-read article, an editor’s footnote, and a quiet recommendation.