For 22 years, my work was measured in people helped, not dollars earned. I led nonprofit organizations, and I loved it. So when I decided to leave that world and start an insurance agency, more than a few people thought I had lost my mind.
I understood why. Insurance doesn't exactly have a reputation for putting people first. But I had seen something in my nonprofit years that wouldn't let me go: families sitting across from me, confused and anxious about their healthcare, with no one they trusted to explain it. Many of them were seniors facing Medicare decisions that would shape the rest of their lives.
Nine years later, Joseph Insurance Broker serves more than 1,100 clients across over 30 states. Here's what that leap taught me about building something that lasts.
Lesson 1: Service is a business model, not a sacrifice
I used to believe you had to choose between doing good and doing well. The nonprofit world taught me to serve. It took me years to realize that serving people well is also the most durable way to build a business.
When you genuinely help someone, they remember. They come back. They send their neighbor, their sister, their friend from church. Nearly every client we have can be traced back to a relationship, not an ad.
The mission didn't change when I left nonprofit work. Only the vehicle did.
Lesson 2: Nobody builds alone
We love the story of the founder who did it all by himself. It's almost never true, and it certainly isn't true for me.
Christian Brindle, my mentor, helped me see that the heart I brought to nonprofit work didn't have to stay behind. It could become the foundation of a business. Glen Shelton believed in me when the path was still uncertain, and his encouragement pushed me forward when it would have been easier to turn back.
If you're early in your journey, find your Christian and your Glen. Then, someday, become one for someone else. The best investment anyone ever made in me wasn't money. It was time and belief.
Lesson 3: Be the educator, not the salesperson
Medicare is confusing by design. Every fall, seniors are buried in mailers, TV ads, and phone calls. Most of them don't need another pitch. They need someone to sit down, slow down, and explain.
So that's what we do. Our agents are trained to teach first. If a client walks away understanding their options, even if they don't buy anything from us that day, we consider it a win. More often than not, they come back, and they bring someone with them.
Our tagline is "We Medi CARE," and we mean it literally. In any industry, the leader who educates earns a level of trust that no sales script can buy.
Lesson 4: Lead people who don't have to follow you
Our agency runs on about 26 independent agents spread across the country. They're 1099 contractors. Legally, none of them have to listen to me.
That's the best leadership training I've ever had. You can't lead independent people with authority. You lead them with clarity, support, and shared values. My nonprofit years prepared me well here because volunteers don't have to show up either. You earn their commitment every single day.
The lesson for any founder: lead as if everyone on your team could walk away tomorrow. The ones who stay will be there because they believe in what you're building.
The leap is worth it
If you're standing at the edge of your own leap, wondering whether your past experience counts in a new arena, here's what I know: it counts more than you think. Everything I learned in 22 years of service became the backbone of my business.
Build on what you already know. Surround yourself with people who believe in you. Teach before you sell. And treat every person, whether client, agent, or neighbor, as if the relationship will last a lifetime. In my experience, the good ones do.
Peter R. Joseph is the founder and CEO of Joseph Insurance Broker LLC, an independent brokerage headquartered in Chino, California, specializing in Medicare, health, life, and retirement planning. Before founding the agency, he spent 22 years in nonprofit leadership. Connect with him at josephinsurancebroker.com.