Share your voice — Be featured in Notable Men
LEADERSHIP

The Leadership Move Nobody Talks About

On love, accountability, and why you need both or neither

November 3, 2026 5 min read

Andy Bachert, Chief Operations Officer on Notable Men

Andy Bachert

Chief Operations Officer, Friends In Action International

The Leadership Move Nobody Talks About

Most leaders are good at one of these two things.

Some leaders are good at love: warmth, encouragement, relationships, and creating an environment where people feel safe, valued, and glad to come to work. Their teams like them. They’re easy to be around. But when performance slips or someone needs a hard conversation, they go quiet. The relationship feels too important to risk. So the problem festers, and the team quietly loses respect for a leader who sees the issue and won’t name it.

Other leaders are good at accountability: clear expectations, direct feedback, and no tolerance for excuses. Their teams know exactly where they stand. But the challenge feels cold. The feedback lands like criticism rather than investment. People comply, but they don’t commit. They follow because they have to, not because they want to.

Jon Gordon has a name for the posture that holds both: Love Tough.

And I think it’s one of the most important and least practiced leadership stances there is.

The sequence matters.

Love comes first. Not as a strategy but as a genuine orientation toward the people you lead. You actually care about them. Not their performance. Them. Their growth, their flourishing, their lives beyond the work.

When that love is real and felt, when people genuinely know you’re for them, then your challenge carries a completely different weight. It’s no longer criticism. It’s an act of love. You’re saying:

I see more in you than you’re currently giving, and I care too much about you to let you stay here.

That’s a very different conversation than the same words delivered without the relational foundation.



I’ve gotten this wrong in both directions. My #2 “strength,” as described by CliftonStrengths Finder, is RELATOR. I am highly focused on relationships.

However, I’ve led seasons where I prioritized the relationship so heavily that I avoided conversations I should have had. I told myself I was being gracious. What I was actually doing was protecting my own comfort at the expense of someone else’s growth. That’s not love. That’s conflict avoidance wearing love’s clothing.

For example, I’ve held on to employees who may not have been in the right seat or even on the right bus. Looking back, I now recognize that I could actually have been holding someone back from something greater.

And I’ve led seasons where I was so focused on the business and the operational demands that I delivered accountability without enough warmth behind it. The feedback may have been accurate, but the relationship wasn’t deep enough to hold it. And the person on the receiving end didn’t feel challenged; they felt evaluated.

I also have an example of this extreme, too. I remember early on in leadership losing my temper and actually slamming my hand on the desk as I kicked someone out of my office and dismissed them from their job. That’s not Love Tough. That’s just tough.

The balance isn’t 50/50. It’s not even a balance, exactly. It’s a sequence: love first, always, genuinely, and then, because of that love, the willingness to say the hard thing.

In Gordon’s book, “The 7 Commitments of a Great Team,” there’s a scene where a team goes through a brutal exercise, writing on paper what’s holding each teammate back and then reading it out loud in front of everyone. It’s the hardest scene in the book. And it works, not because the feedback was delivered skillfully, but because the team had spent months building genuine love and connection before they ever got to that moment.

Without the connection, that exercise would have been devastating. With it, it was transformational.

The hard conversation is only as good as the relationship it lives inside.

Transitioning from 30 years in secular business to now leading a faith-based organization, I’ve come to the realization that, for leaders in ministry contexts, this has a particular nuance worth naming.

We (I) often use grace as a reason to avoid hard conversations. We frame conflict avoidance as pastoral sensitivity. We confuse gentleness with permissiveness. And in doing so, we actually fail the people we’re called to develop because real love doesn’t leave people where it finds them.

The most loving thing a leader can do for someone who is underperforming, drifting, or operating below their character is to name it.

The most loving thing a leader can do for someone who is underperforming, drifting, or operating below their character is to name it. Clearly and kindly, but with the full weight of genuine care behind it.

Not to shame them. To call them up.

Looking back, it’s what the best leaders in my life have done for me: caught me at a deficit, looked me in the eye, and said, this isn’t who you are, and I think you know it. Sure, it may have hurt in the moment, but knowing the relationship was built on love and friendship, my temporary pain led to continual growth.

This week, is there someone on your team, in your organization, or in your family who needs a hard conversation that you’ve been avoiding?

Ask yourself honestly: Have I built enough relational foundation that this conversation will land as love and not just as criticism?

If yes, have the conversation this week. Don’t wait for a better moment.

If no, start building. The conversation can most likely wait a little longer. The relationship can’t.

THE SUNDAY DISPATCH

The Week's Most Considered Piece, Delivered.

One letter every Sunday. The most-read article, an editor’s footnote, and a quiet recommendation.