The Question That Started This
People change. Sometimes not a little, but at the root: who they are, who they live with, where they live, what they believe, and what they're for. And they've apparently been doing it for as long as there have been people.
I was thirty-five and had just celebrated ten years of sobriety when it struck me. I was miserable. I had spent the past ten years adapting to an identity that I had not actively chosen. No longer an active addict, I now identified as a "recovering addict." Was that all that life had to offer? Becoming the opposition to the identity I had left while still orbiting the central theme of addiction? There had to be more to life than this.
This article asks two questions:
- Have humans always undergone recognizable processes of fundamental identity reorganization when an experience disrupts their relationship with themselves, their environment, and their social world?
- Do the same movements appear repeatedly across cultures, eras, and circumstances, sometimes producing lasting positive change?
Threshold Reorganization™ (TR™) proposes that the answer to both may be yes. This article presents TR™ as a theory: a way of organizing evidence, not a finished fact. Where the evidence is strong, I'll say so. Where TR™ is hypothesizing, I'll say that, too.
Five Movements
TR™ describes identity reorganization through five movements:
- Recognition: Acknowledging a fundamental disruption or incompatibility with an existing identity.
- Separation: Departing from former roles, relationships, environments, or organizing structures.
- Liminality: The in-between period when the old identity no longer organizes experience and the new one hasn't yet formed.
- Reorganization: Building new identity structures, relationships, environments, and supports.
- Integration: Consolidating those changes into an enduring way of living.
Two cautions up front. These are investigative parallels, not a claim that every person or historical case contains all five movements or moves through them in a fixed order. And I am not claiming that people throughout history practiced TR™. The proposal is narrower and more defensible: history may contain a naturally occurring process of identity and environmental reorganization that TR™ offers a way to recognize, describe, and test.
The evidence may be thousands of years older than the terminology.
Level 1: Historical Recurrence
If identity reorganization is a real human process, I'd expect societies to have noticed it, and many did, independently.
Rites of Passage
In 1909, the anthropologist Arnold van Gennep observed that transitions between social identities (child to adult, single to married, outsider to member) tend to follow three phases: separation, transition, and incorporation. Victor Turner later developed the middle phase into the concept of liminality, the threshold state of being "betwixt and between," where the old structure has dissolved and the new one isn't yet in place.
The parallels to Separation, Liminality, and Integration are hard to miss. The interesting question isn't whether societies ritualized change. It's why so many, in so many places, built structured processes for moving a person from one identity to another. One plausible answer: the underlying process was already there, and the rituals were scaffolding around it.
Pilgrimage, Conversion, and Spiritual Transformation
Across religious traditions, we can find accounts of people leaving the familiar, passing through disorientation and uncertainty, undergoing a profound shift in worldview, and returning to a changed life and community. William James catalogued such conversions in The Varieties of Religious Experience (1902). Victor and Edith Turner examined pilgrimage as a socially sanctioned threshold. Narratives of founders who leave a former life (a prince who walks out of a palace, a persecutor transformed on a road) are common enough to suggest the pattern is culturally resonant, though they are stories, not data, and should be treated as such.
Migration and Displacement
Exile, immigration, and resettlement disrupt far more than geography. They disrupt roles, relationships, language, status, and the environments that held an identity in place. Some people experience prolonged disorientation; others build substantially new lives. That divergence is exactly what a theory of reorganization should be able to explain.
Returning from War and Other Major Disruptions
Warriors returning home, disaster survivors, people recovering from addiction, and people rebuilding after catastrophic loss: in each case, the disruption can be followed by a different relationship to identity, purpose, and community. Many cultures developed rituals of return and reintegration for returning fighters, which suggests reintegration was recognized as a distinct, difficult stage rather than something that happens automatically.
Collective Transformation (Speculative)
Communities also pass through social, political, and cultural upheavals. Whether the same movements can be recognized at a collective scale is an open and more speculative question. I flag it as a direction, not a claim.
Level 2: What Contemporary Research Observes
Modern research has examined parts of this territory without using TR™'s language.
- Quantum change. William Miller and Janet C'de Baca (2001) studied people who reported sudden, profound shifts in identity, values, and behavior that proved lasting.
- Narrative identity. Dan McAdams's work shows that people actively reconstruct their life stories after upheaval and that the structure of those stories is associated with well-being.
- Post-traumatic growth. Tedeschi and Calhoun's research documents positive psychological change following adversity.
- Addiction recovery and identity. Recovery literature, including accounts of spiritual experience in Alcoholics Anonymous, describes profound changes in personality, outlook, and ways of living that extend beyond abstinence (Alcoholics Anonymous World Services, 2001).
- Neuroscience of learning and plasticity. These fields may offer a biological explanation for enduring behavioral reorganization. This remains a theoretical possibility within TR™ rather than an established mechanism.
None of this proves TR™. These are bodies of literature, research, and theoretical possibilities against which TR™'s propositions can be examined.
The Positive Outcomes Worth Investigating
Surviving a disruption isn't the same as being transformed by it, and temporary improvement isn't the same as integration. The proposition TR™ explores is that certain configurations of these movements are associated with sustainable change:
- Greater coherence between identity and behavior
- Increased agency and autonomy
- More sustainable relationships
- Better alignment between a person and their environment
- Renewed purpose and meaning
- Greater resilience when later disruptions arrive
- Reduced dependence on former coping mechanisms or identities
My own transformation took root when I began to explore the values and behaviors I wished to embody. Rather than simply walking away from the addict identity, I was actively moving toward a defined life that I wished to live. Visualization, coupled with the active pursuit of new experiences, created the framework I had previously lacked. Moving away from an undesired identity creates distance but does not facilitate lasting change. Once I began moving toward something entirely different, it became possible to believe change was attainable.
The Other Side: When Reorganization Fails
A theory that only explains success is a story. TR™ must be able to account for people who pass through disruption and don't land well. The following are possible outcomes I propose as research categories, not diagnoses:
Outcome
What I'm Looking For
Successful integration
New identity is coherent and sustainable
Incomplete integration
Significant change, but identity remains unstable
Prolonged liminality
Old identity dissolved; new one hasn't consolidated
Maladaptive reorganization
A new identity forms, but functioning or relationships deteriorate
Identity destabilization
Increasing fragmentation, confusion, or instability
Regression
Return to previous patterns or identities
The distinction between incomplete and maladaptive matters: forming a new identity doesn't guarantee a good one.
Existing research already points in this direction (each item below was checked against its published abstract or record; read the full papers for concise numbers):
- Military reintegration. Mitchell, Frazier, and Sayer (2020) analyzed 244 Afghanistan and Iraq veterans who reported reintegration difficulty and were enrolled in an expressive-writing trial. Forty-nine percent (n = 121) described identity disruption in their writing. That group had more severe PTSD symptoms, lower satisfaction with life, and greater reintegration difficulty at baseline, as well as less improvement in social support over time. Caveats: The sample was selected for reintegration difficulty, so 49% is not a rate for veterans in general, and the design cannot show that disruption caused the outcomes.
- Loss of military identity. Markowitz, Kintzle, and Castro (2023) surveyed 783 post-9/11 veterans in the Chicago and San Francisco areas. Unmet needs at discharge and perceived loss of military identity were associated with more risky behavior, with much of that effect running through depression and resentment toward civilians. It is a survey, so it shows associations, but it fits the idea that a disrupted identity without a supportive replacement environment carries risk.
- Older adults during COVID-19. Mitchell and colleagues (2024) followed 2,248 older adults from April/May 2020 to April/May 2021. Many reported positive identity themes, such as revised priorities and a new awareness of their own strength. Others reported identity disruption, which was associated with worse well-being at baseline and persistently worse well-being over the year. A preliminary 2025 four-year follow-up abstract reports that about 6% indicated disruption, with lower mental-health trajectories and rising loneliness. The same upheaval produced divergent outcomes.
- Leaving religious communities. Nica (2020) interviewed 24 former members of fundamentalist religions about how they reconstruct identity in relation to well-being, and Ebaugh's (1988) role-exit model frames leaving a role as a multistage process. A 2023 master's paper (Haire) applies that model to religious exit, arguing that the conflict of leaving drives distress while exit can also relieve strain from the former environment. That paper is not peer-reviewed, so treat it as a pointer, not evidence.
- Perceived versus actual growth. Boals, Bedford, and Callahan (2019) followed 64 college students who experienced trauma during a semester. Higher self-reported post-traumatic growth was related to increased distress and more avoidance coping, while measured change in growth-related domains was related to decreased distress. This replicates the pattern in Frazier and colleagues (2009). The samples are students, and no one has yet tested this for identity reorganization specifically, so TR™ would need its own way to distinguish genuine integration from the belief that one has transformed.
What Might Distinguish the Outcomes?
This is where TR™ moves from interesting narrative to testable theory. The central question:
What differentiates people who experience enduring positive transformation after significant identity disruption from those who experience prolonged instability, maladaptive reconstruction, or decline?
TR™ proposes investigating four possibilities:
- Does the absence of meaningful social support interfere with reorganization?
- Does environmental incompatibility undermine an otherwise positive identity change?
- Can someone build a new identity without integrating their past, present, and anticipated future selves?
- Can someone appear transformed while their psychological or social functioning actually deteriorates?
If research repeatedly shows that identity disruption combined with environmental instability, relational disconnection, and inadequate support predicts worse outcomes, that would bear directly on TR™'s central propositions about identity, environment, relationships, and support systems.
What Would Make This a Theory and Not Just a Story?
TR™ earns credibility to the extent that it can be challenged. Three levels of evidence are proposed:
- Level 1, historical recurrence: Recognizable movements appear across societies and eras (this article's middle sections).
- Level 2, contemporary observation: Similar movements are documented in individual transformation, recovery, and reintegration.
- Level 3, explanatory plausibility: The movements are not coincidental sequences but a meaningful process through which enduring change occurs.
Level 3 is the hardest. To get there, TR™ needs to specify what initiates the process, what separates reorganization from prolonged liminality, what separates integration from temporary improvement, whether the movements can be observed independently of the TR™ framework, and what predictions it makes that evidence could contradict.
Why It Matters Now
If identity reorganization is a natural human process, then how a society treats it matters. Many modern systems (clinical, educational, and workplace) treat sudden identity change as pathology to be stabilized or as an inconvenience to be managed. Traditional societies often built structures around it: elders, rituals, and communities that held people through the threshold.
If modern cultures wish to eliminate generational trauma and the impact that incomplete identity transformation has on society, we may benefit from a more holistic approach to transformation. Rather than developing new definitions of pathology or adopting new treatment protocols, we may find lessons in anthropology more effective in building stronger, more resilient individuals within our communities. Many people still say, "It takes a village," but what would it look like if we put that belief back into practice?
I don't want to romanticize disruption. The question TR™ raises is whether the process can be recognized early, whether people can be supported through the in-between, and whether reorganization that is working can be distinguished from reorganization that is failing.
What I Am Not Claiming
- That humans consciously practiced TR™.
- That every historical example contains all five movements or follows them in order.
- That transformation is always positive.
- That the research above proves TR™. It supports the plausibility of testing it.
TR™ is best read as a theory of human transformation, with trauma recovery as one important application.
References
Alcoholics Anonymous World Services, Inc. (2001). Alcoholics Anonymous: The story of how many thousands of men and women have recovered from alcoholism (4th ed.). Alcoholics Anonymous World Services.
Boals, A., Bedford, L. A., & Callahan, J. L. (2019). Perceptions of change after a trauma and perceived posttraumatic growth: A prospective examination. Behavioral Sciences, 9(1), Article 10. https://doi.org/10.3390/bs9010010
Ebaugh, H. R. F. (1988). Becoming an ex: The process of role exit. University of Chicago Press.
Frazier, P., Tennen, H., Gavian, M., Park, C., Tomich, P., & Tashiro, T. (2009). Does self-reported posttraumatic growth reflect genuine positive change? Psychological Science, 20(7), 912–919. https://doi.org/10.1111/j.1467-9280.2009.02381.x
Haire, F. (2023). “Born again”: Narrating the mental health journeys of religious exiters [Master's alternative plan paper, Minnesota State University, Mankato]. Cornerstone. https://cornerstone.lib.mnsu.edu/etds/1400
James, W. (1902). The varieties of religious experience: A study in human nature. Longmans, Green, and Co.
Markowitz, F. E., Kintzle, S., & Castro, C. A. (2023). Military-to-civilian transition strains and risky behavior among post-9/11 veterans. Military Psychology, 35(1), 38–49. https://doi.org/10.1080/08995605.2022.2065177
McAdams, D. P., & McLean, K. C. (2013). Narrative identity. Current Directions in Psychological Science, 22(3), 233–238. https://doi.org/10.1177/0963721413475622
Miller, W. R., & C'de Baca, J. (2001). Quantum change: When epiphanies and sudden insights transform ordinary lives. Guilford Press.
Mitchell, L., & Finlay, J. (2025). Older adults' identity development and mental health after the COVID-19 pandemic: A 4-year longitudinal study [Conference abstract]. Innovation in Aging, 9(Supplement 2), Article igaf122.1762. https://doi.org/10.1093/geroni/igaf122.1762
Mitchell, L. L., Burns, M. K., Impellizzeri, D. K., Falso, V. R., Famularo, M., & Finlay, J. M. (2024). Identity development and disruption in older adults during COVID-19: A longitudinal, mixed-methods study. The Journals of Gerontology: Series B, 79(5), Article gbae017. https://doi.org/10.1093/geronb/gbae017
Mitchell, L. L., Frazier, P. A., & Sayer, N. A. (2020). Identity disruption and its association with mental health among veterans with reintegration difficulty. Developmental Psychology, 56(11), 2152–2166. https://doi.org/10.1037/dev0001106
Nica, A. A. (2020). Leaving my religion: How ex-fundamentalists reconstruct identity related to well-being. Journal of Religion and Health, 59(4), 2120–2134. https://doi.org/10.1007/s10943-019-00975-8
Orazem, R. J., Frazier, P. A., Schnurr, P. P., Oleson, H. E., Carlson, K. F., Litz, B. T., & Sayer, N. A. (2017). Identity adjustment among Afghanistan and Iraq war veterans with reintegration difficulty. Psychological Trauma: Theory, Research, Practice, and Policy, 9(Suppl. 1), 4–11. https://doi.org/10.1037/tra0000225
Tedeschi, R. G., & Calhoun, L. G. (1996). The Posttraumatic Growth Inventory: Measuring the positive legacy of trauma. Journal of Traumatic Stress, 9(3), 455–471. https://doi.org/10.1002/jts.2490090305
Turner, V. (1969). The ritual process: Structure and anti-structure. Aldine Publishing Company.
Turner, V., & Turner, E. (1978). Image and pilgrimage in Christian culture: Anthropological perspectives. Columbia University Press.
van Gennep, A. (1909). Les rites de passage. Émile Nourry.
Have you been through a disruption that reorganized who you are? What did the in-between feel like, and what or who helped you land?